Auto Quest – An American Experience

Auto Quest – An American Experience

I was not sure it was the right time to start the quest. Now, I am almost sure it was the wrong time.  Should I continue?  Life is full of these decisions.

It seemed straightforward.  An almost constant companion of 30 years was letting me down.  Specifically, she was losing her cool over the past year.  There were other small things too, not that they mattered much between companions on the roads of life.  The condition was diagnosed and a time was scheduled for the work.  It seemed like just another bump in the road for me and my wagon. It seemed like what should be expected from a 30 y/o mechanical friend. 

 I had seen her on a used car lot in the spring of 1998.  A low, sleek, beautiful 1995 wagon, a model I had admired for several years.  She had experienced very low mileage from her leaser and now was up for sale.  After a couple of months and a few thousand dollars, she became part of the family.  In her first years she was my wife’s car, being the newest of our fleet of two.  As she aged and was no longer the newest, my turn came as her designated driver and our love affair blossomed.

Now, here’s the story about that bump in the road and losing her cool.  Her air conditioning died early this spring.  Living in the desert is wonderful if you have air conditioning.  Without it, well that is a different story.  Parts were needed and hard to find.  After waiting six weeks, all expected parts were on hand and the work was scheduled.  Once at her second home, my local Mercedes shop where I do believe they love her as much as I do, the work began.  Unfortunately and unexpectantly, another part was needed.  She stayed in the shop for three weeks till it arrived.  

The cost was surprisingly not prohibitive, not even the sales tax of an average used car, but the loss of my car for almost three months, was.  In a decade or so they will be coming to take my license away.  Before that, I, like most Americans, need those wheels. That was when I decided it was time to shop for a replacement.  Maybe it was the wrong decision.

Car shopping for the first time in over a decade, I found that while much remains the same, much has changed.  The showrooms, sticker shock and the pesky sales people remain.  The internet, the products and the test drive have changed in unexpected ways.

Did you know you can buy a car sight unseen and without a test drive?  Yes, you can and it will be delivered directly to your home: the magic of the internet at work.  Fortunately, the companies that sell cars that way have a return policy.  

My favorite vehicular companions over the years were purchased after satisfying test drives or as a rental drive.  I will be reluctant to purchase a car over the internet unless I have had experience with it otherwise.

“What about the new cars?” you may ask.  They are a problem.  There are drivetrain choices, body style options and of course, the accessory packages.  The drivetrain choices include gas (4, 6, & 8 cylinders with or without turbochargers), electric and hybrid models.  The body style options are sedans, wagons, sports utility vehicles (SUVs), minivans and sports cars.  Trucks are a different matter. The accessory packages vary from basic needs to the unbelievable.

It is easiest to address the drivetrain and body style options together.  The number of plain gas engine cars has declined dramatically.  They are seen for the most part in entry level, luxury or sports car models. All the rest, actually most, are 4 cylinder hybrid engines.  American manufacturers have almost completely quit making sedans and none currently make ones with 6 or 8 cylinder engines.  For a typical sedan with a 6 or 8 cylinder gas engine the choices are limited to the upper end of the luxury brands.  The auto industry is focused on making all their vehicles go from zero to 60 in less than 10 seconds, while achieving an average gas mileage of 25 miles per gallon.  

The first goal is most likely driven by consumers and the latter by government regulations.  Trucks, however, defined separately by the government, are regulated differently and less stringently.  I knew that government requirements had changed the automotive industry, but it was my car shopping experience that brought the effects of the regulations into focus.  General Motors only makes sedans in its Cadillac division. Ford and Stellantis (formerly Crysler) only make sports (American muscle) cars.  Honda, Nissan and Toyota still make sedans.  Almost all these models have only 4 cylinder engines or 4 cylinder hybrid engines.  All the manufacturers focus on the SUV models.  The SUVs seem to come in small, medium and large sizes.  Small and medium SUVs are powered for the most part by 4 cylinder or 4 cylinder hybrid engines.  

Once one has wandered through the confusion of body style and drivetrain options, it is time to consider accessories.  Here, confusion moves to chaos.  Do you want 6, 12 or 15 speakers?  How about a sunroof, moonroof or no roof at all.  Do you want your derriere to be on fabric, synthetic leather, one of those with leather trim or actual leather?  Of course, there is always the upgraded leather for those with tender derrieres. It can be cooled or heated.  How about color?  Oh, for the days of Henry Ford, when you could get any color you wanted as long as it was black.  For most brands and models, the colors are limited by the trim (engine and accessory package) base model that you choose.  Of course, there are options for both inside and out, but at a cost.

After my initial bewilderment at the options I faced, instinct kicked in.  Keep it simple stupid.  I would look for a 6 cylinder wagon or sedan with specific features that drove as nicely as my 30 year-old wagon.  Boy, was I in for a surprise.

Although I didn’t want to purchase a car over the internet, it was a way to navigate the models and options I might want.  Once that process was completed, the disappointment set in.  You see, a buyer’s choices are limited by the dealers’ inventory and ordering limitations.  I rarely found a car locally that was near what I created on the websites. For the most part they came with many options, some I wanted, many I didn’t. 

I found myself in a chaotic mess, but the worst was yet to come – the test drive.  I did my internet work.  I identified what I needed, what I would accept and what I wanted to spend.  There were three models that met my criteria.  With this information, I gathered my fortitude and went to the dealerships.  On my first visits I inspected the models and made sure that they would be acceptable long term.  I checked out the headroom, getting in and out, the dashboard layout (real buttons and screens) and the seat comfort.  All three passed my inspection.  I then scheduled a test drive for each.  To jump to the end of the story, I knew by the time I was able to get the first two off the lot and to the first stop sign, I would not want to drive them for any length of time.  The third drove better and took me a couple of miles before I was sure that I did not want it either.  Have you ever steered a boat?  You get the idea.  

The real story of the test drives is a tale of the modern tendency of manufacturers to follow the old contractor’s adage “while you doing, why don’t you,” or in their case, “If we are going to, we can do this too.”

The test drive was usually in a vehicle that I could have easily purchased based upon its looks, qualifications and color.  It seems to begin with a walkaround introduction to the prospective new family member with a description of its attributes.  When I entered the car further instructions and descriptions followed.  Seat position, buttons, touch screen, shifter, brakes, infotainment options……  I only wanted to drive the thing.  After my driver’s seat ‘check-out’, I was advised that full instructions were given upon purchase.  You can imagine my fear of the full instructions.  I envisioned a daylong event with both classroom and one-on-one instructor guided time.  I was sure an essay test would follow with passing required before I could take my new car off the lot.  I did not need nor want most of those features. I always thought I could pass on those 12 to 15 speakers.

You know my impressions of the drive, all three failed.  The next issue was getting out of the car and off the lot.  I have to smile when I think of how hard the poor salespeople work to convince you what a good choice it is, how a great deal could made today and how much their manager would like to meet you.  Another segment of my time on the planet disappears into the ethers. 

My lesson.  Do your homework.  Decide on models, trims, colors, required options and budget before going to look at sheet metal and be sure you may want to buy it before you spend another 2 hours for a test drive.  As for me, the internet purchase with the trial period option is appearing better and better. 

Maybe if I wait, manufacturers will once again manufacture cars for their customers, the daily drivers and most buyers.  The current crop of new automobiles appears to be made for the frugal, the technology chasers, the speed obsessed and our politicians. What is needed is a midsize or larger sedan or wagon with a simple, strong drivetrain at a reasonable price.  

Life with my current love, a 1995 Mercedes E Class wagon, may need to be extended till they come for my license, if the new air conditioning last that long.

RGH 30,232

THE FLOW VOLUME LOOP

THE FLOW VOLUME LOOP

Winston

Your interest in medicine outside of your specialty continues to surprise me.  Yes, on a number of occasions I have mentioned the importance of the flow volume loop in testing lung functions. It has remained an interest of mine throughout my medical career. I am sure I can provide much more information than you want to know, as I was present at its birth for general use as a clinical test.

 The flow volume loop is a gift to the physician. An understanding of its secrets gives the knowledgeable practitioner a world of information. It can explain or help to explain the symptoms of dyspnea and other breathing complaints. Careful review reveals more profound secrets: the unacknowledged secrets of how to understand expiratory flow, and its problems.

My love affair with the flow volume loop began in 1974 when I was made head of the pulmonary function laboratory at Walter Reed Army Medical Center. I was a newbie in the world of pulmonary physiology. Yes, I was a fully trained, knowledgeable and soon to be board certified pulmonary specialist. But the world of physiology was a whole different category of knowledge, information and details – more than any trained pulmonary physician would possess after their training in the specialty. Furthermore, I was following in the footsteps of doctors who had been more thoroughly trained in pulmonary physiology; Sidney Braman and Robert Senior, both of whom went on to extraordinary careers in academic medicine.

Drs. Hyatt and Black had just published on the value of the flow volume loop as a measurement to diagnose airflow obstructions in the trachea and larynx. The flow volume loop had not been part of our education and most patient testing facilities were not set up to make those measurements, the Walter Reed Pulmonary Testing Laboratory included.  That time was before the computation of medical testing and widespread computer use in general. Flow and volume lung tests were done manually and the flow volume loop was not available to the clinician. Fortunately, or unfortunately, it is now present on almost every commercial device that measures expiratory airflow. I believe that by being so widely available, their value is being overlooked.

The technology of the 70s was evolving rapidly. Physicians were trained to understand expiratory volumes and their timing. They were also instructed in measuring basic gas changes in the blood, lung size in health and disease and the ability of gas to enter the bloodstream.  These measurements were rapidly becoming common tools in the practice of clinical medicine; so too, would the new test of lung function, the flow volume loop.

Physiologists in pulmonary research had learned to measure the speed or velocity of flow with the device called a pneumotact.  It provided an instant electronic signal that reflected the velocity of flowing air.  Prior to that ability, volumes were measured manually and flow calculated indirectly from paper recordings.  The pneumotact could be calibrated to measure the speed with which air was moving. In the 1970s this was cutting edge.  Now, over 50 years later, much cheaper, more stable and reliable but similar types of devices can perform the same function and are widely available for clinical use. Almost every device currently available to measure expiratory airflow does it with some sort of electronic measurement.

The volume of air exhaled traditionally had been measured by the displacement that air would cause into a sealed container. As the air changed the position of the container, it would create a mark on paper. The inscribed marks could be physically measured and the volume of air calculated. This volume displacement was developed in the late 19th and early 20th century. In the mid 20th century, the time it took to exhale the air into the container was added as a measure of lung function.  Spirometry, as it was named, had been the only pulmonary function test for measuring aspects of lung function through the 20th century and remains a mainstay of lung testing in clinical medicine today.

As a neophyte in the world of physiology, I was both frustrated and fascinated by the problems of measuring and using the flow loop.  Reports by Miller and Hyatt, and then Black and Hyatt, chose to display the two parameters on an XY axis. These values needed to be measured simultaneously and plotted one verses the other.  It could be projected on an oscilloscope (think of a digital screen with a line drawn on it) or on a special paper recorder.  Traditionally, with spirometry testing of expiratory airflow, clinical test parameters evaluated were measurements of time on one axis and volume on the other. Those were the manually measured values.  The addition of the simultaneous measurements of flow and volume, as well as the change in how they were presented, made the flow volume loop unique.

For other reasons, the lab at Walter Reed was well equipped.  Previous directors had requested and received pneumotacts for use with other studies. They provided a way for me to measure the flow portion of the test.  Within a few months, I was able to obtain the appropriate devices to measure volume and the special x-y recorder needed. With more than a little help from my knowledgeable staff, we created a digital signal for volume, flow, and time and then recorded them on the x-y recorder.  I soon incorporated our measurement of the flow volume loop as a clinical tool.  In the late 70s, subsequent upgraded testing equipment simplified these.  But always in the back of my mind, those early tools brought joy to my reviews of the flow volume tests in my work.

As you can see Winston, in a relatively short period of time I was able to make the flow volume loop a clinical test available as part of the pulmonary function studies.  But that was just the beginning.

 Let me know if you desire more information.  If you do, it may open Pandora’s flow volume box. If so, I think you would find it an interesting and valuable container. 

Robert E. Hyatt MD and Black LF

                  Am Rev Respir Dis. 1973 Feb;107(2):191-9. doi: 10.1164/arrd.1973.107.2.191

RGH WeWi43,29,615